DOI: https://doi.org/10.30837/2522-9818.2018.6.050

THE ANALYSIS OF EXISTING APPROACHES TO CALCULATING TRAFFIC SAFETY CRITERIA IN THE RAILWAY SECTOR

Андрій Ярославович Кузишин, Андрій Васильович Батіг

Abstract


The subject matter of the article is the methods for determining the safety parameters to prevent wheel derailment. The object of the study is the interaction of a rail track and rolling stock. The goal of the paper is to study of approaches that are used by domestic and foreign scientists to assess the protection against wheel derailment and to study the analytical conditions for the wheel flange rolling onto the rail top, which are the criteria of protection against derailment which are considered while expertizing the railway transport. The methods used in this work are the system, logical and historical approaches; analysis and synthesis, induction and deduction; modelling. The tasks of the article are as follows: to analyze the methods for determining the safety criteria from wheel derailment; to evaluate the importance of all methods and approaches, to identify their disadvantages and advantages, to make recommendations for improving the method of assessing the stability of rail vehicles on the railways of Ukraine. Results. The works of domestic and foreign scientists, which are devoted to the issue of assessing the protection against the wheel derailment were analyzed. It has been established that in order to approximate the results of mathematical modelling of rolling stock to the actual operating conditions, the task of the wheelset derailing from the track should be performed using dynamic equations of spatial oscillations. It was proposed to take into account the analytical conditions for wheel flange rolling onto the rail top, which were proposed by  E. Sokol, the Doctor of Technical Sciences, when expertizing the railway transport. Conclusions. Most of the considered methods estimate the probability of a wheelset derailment without taking into account the influence of other wheelsets, which can lead to erroneous results. It has been established that in order to approximate the results of theoretical calculations to the experimental data, the problem of the wheel derailment should be solved using the equations of spatial oscillations of a rail car.

Keywords


wheel derailment; wheelset; wheel flange; railway transport expertise; traffic safety

References


Masliev, V. G. (2002), "Dynamics of a locomotive with a device for radial installation of wheel pairs in curves" ["Dinamika lokomotiva s ustrojstvom dlja radial'noj ustanovki kolesnyh par v krivyh"], Vіsnik Shіdnoukr. nac. un-tu. Tehnіchnі nauki. Serіja Transport, No. 6 (52), P. 69–74.

Azovskij, A. P., Koturanov, V. N., Ovechnikov, M. N., Plotnikov, I. V. (2007), On the assessment the stability of the wheel from rolling out on the rail head [Ob ocenke zapasa ustojchivosti kolesa ot vykatyvanija na golovku rel'sa], Sbornik statej mezhdunarodnoj konferencii "Bezopasnost' dvizhenija poezdov". M.: MIIT, S. VI-1-VI-2.

Koturanov, V. N., Ivanov, D. V., Petrov, A. G. (2010), "The method of calculating the wheel's stability margin against derailment" ["Metod rascheta zapasa ustojchivosti kolesa protiv shoda s rel'sa"], Trudy konferencii "Bezopasnost' dvizhenija", Moscow : MIIT, P. VII–24.

Kogan, A. Ja., Chernjakov, E. A. (2008), "Assessment of the sufficient condition of wheel stability on the rail, taking into account the probabilistic nature of certain factors affecting it" ["Ocenka dostatochnogo uslovija ustojchivosti kolesa na rel'se s uchetom verojatnostnogo haraktera vlijajushhego na nee nekotoryh faktorov"], Vestnik VNIIZhT, No. 2, P. 36–41.

Trofimov, A. N. (1983), "On the stability of rolling stock against derailment" ["Ob ustojchivosti podvizhnogo sostava protiv shoda s rel'sov"], Trudy DIIT, Issue 228/25, P. 23–26.

Prokudin, I., Vinogradov, V., Vorob'ev, Je. (2003), "Time to get out of the shadows" ["Pora vyjti iz teni"], Gudok.

Vinnik, L. V., Burchak, G. P. (2005), "Comments on the use of the Nadal criterion in evaluating derailment safety" ["Zamechanija po povodu ispol'zovanija kriterija Nadalja pri ocenke bezopasnosti shoda s rel's"], Vіsnik Shіdnoukr. nacіon.unіver. іm. V. Dalja, No. 8, Part 1, P. 108–113.

Elkins, J., Huimun, Wu. (2000), "New Criteria for Flange Climb Derailment", 2000 ASME/IEEE Joint Railroad Conference,

P. 1–7.

Evans, J., Berg, M. (2009), ""Challenges in simulation of rail vehicle dynamics, Vehicle System Dynamics: International Journal of Vehicle Mechanics and Mobility, No. 47, P. 1023–1048.

Opala, M. (2012), "Analysis of experimental data in the context of safety against derailment of a railway vehicle", Key Engineering Materials, No. 518, P. 16–23.

Shabana, A. (2012), "Nadal’s formula and high speed rail derailments", J. Comput, Nonlinear Dynam, P. 7.

Elkins, J., Wu, H. (2000), "New criteria for flange climb derailment", Railroad Conference, P. 1–7.

Wu, H., Shu, X., Wilson, N. (2005), "Flange Climb Derailment Criteria and Wheel", Rail Profile Management and Maintenance Guidelines for Transit Operations, TCRP Report, No. 71, P. 5.

Martynov, I. Je., Masliev, V. G., Mokrousov, S. D. (2013), "Wheel flange wear and rail freight cars: the problem and its solutions" ["Iznos grebnej koles gruzovyh vagonov i rel'sov: problema i puti ee reshenija"], Vagonnij park, No. 5 (74), P. 4–7.

Standards for calculating and assessing the strength of bearing elements, dynamic qualities and the impact on the path of the crew part of locomotives r.t. MRC RF track 1520 mm [Normy dlja rascheta i ocenki prochnosti nesushhih jelementov, dinamicheskih kachestv i vozdejstvija na put' jekipazhnoj chasti lokomotivov zh. d. MPS RF kolei 1520 mm], Moscow : MPS RF, VNIIZhT, 1998, 145 p.

Standards for calculating and assessing the strength of the bearing elements and the dynamic qualities of the motor-wagon rolling stock r.t. MRC RF track 1520 mm [Normy rascheta i ocenki prochnosti nesushhih jelementov i dinamicheskih kachestv motorvagonnogo podvizhnogo sostava zh. d. MPS RF kolei 1520 mm], Moscow : MPS RF, VNIIZhT, 1997, 147 p.

Norms for calculating and designing railroad cars of 1520 mm MRC railways (non-self-propelled) with changes [Normy rascheta i proektirovanija vagonov zheleznyh dorog MPS kolei 1520 mm (nesamohodnyh) s izmenenijami], Moscow : GosNIIV-VNIIZhT, 1996, 346 p.

Verigo, M. F., Kogan, A. Ja. (1965), "On the stability of the movement of the wheels on the rail" ["Ob ustojchivosti dvizhenija kolesa po rel'su"], Vestnik VNIIZhT, No. 4, P. 3–7.

Lukin, V. V., Shadur, L. A., Koturonov, V. N., Hohlov, A. A. (2000), Design and calculation of wagons [Konstruirovanie i raschet vagonov], Moscow, 725 p.

Klimenko, I. V. (2015), Development of theoretical foundations and methods for assessing and improving the safety of railway rolling stock [Razvitie teoreticheskih osnov i metodov ocenki i povyshenija bezopasnosti dvizhenija podvizhnogo sostava zheleznyh dorog]: dis. ... d-ra tehn. nauk: 05.22.07, Dnepropetr. nac. un-t zh.-d. tr-ta im. akad. V. Lazarjana, Dnepropetrovsk, 284 p.

Sokol, Je. N. (2004), Derailments and rolling stock collisions [Shody s rel'sov i stolknovenija podvizhnogo sostava (Sudebnaja jekspertiza. Jelementy teorii i praktiki)], Kyiv : Transport Ukraine, 386 p.


GOST Style Citations


1.   Маслиев В. Г. Динамика локомотива с устройством для радиальной установки колесных пар в кривых. Вісник Східноукр. нац. ун-ту. Технічні науки. Серія Транспорт. 2002. № 6 (52). С. 69–74.

2.   Азовский А. П., Котуранов В. Н., Овечников М. Н., Плотников И. В. Об оценке запаса устойчивости колеса от выкатывания на головку рельса. Сборник статей международной конференции "Безопасность движения поездов". М. : МИИТ, 2007. С. VI–1–VI–2.

3.   Котуранов В. Н., Иванов Д. В., Петров А. Г. Метод расчета запаса устойчивости колеса против схода с рельса. Труды конференции "Безопасность движения". М. : МИИТ, 2010. С. VII–24.

4.   Коган А. Я., Черняков Е. А. Оценка достаточного условия устойчивости колеса на рельсе с учетом вероятностного характера влияющего на нее некоторых факторов. Вестник ВНИИЖТ. 2008. № 2. С. 36–41.

5.   Трофимов А. Н. Об устойчивости подвижного состава против схода с рельсов. Труды ДИИТ. 1983. Вып. 228/25. С. 23–26.

6.   Прокудин И., Виноградов В., Воробьев Э. Пора выйти из тени. Гудок. 06.08.2003.

7.   Винник Л. В., Бурчак Г. П. Замечания по поводу использования критерия Надаля при оценке безопасности схода с рельс. Вісник Східноукр. націон.універ. ім. В. Даля. 2005. № 8. Ч. 1. С. 108–113.

8.   Elkins J., Huimun Wu. New Criteria for Flange Climb Derailment.2000 ASME/IEEE Joint Railroad Conference, April 4-6, 2000, P. 1–7.

9.   Evans J., Berg M. Challenges in simulation of rail vehicle dynamics.Vehicle System Dynamics: International Journal of Vehicle Mechanics and Mobility. 2009. No. 47. P. 1023–1048.

10. Opala M. Analysis of experimental data in the context of safety against derailment of a railway vehicle.Key Engineering Materials.2012. No. 518.P. 16–23.

11. Shabana A. Nadal’s formula and high speed rail derailments.J. Comput. Nonlinear Dynam. 2012.No. 7.

12. Elkins J., Wu H. New criteria for flange climb derailment.Railroad Conference.2000. P. 1–7.

13. Wu H., Shu X., Wilson N. Flange Climb Derailment Criteria and Wheel. Rail Profile Management and Maintenance Guidelines for Transit Operations. TCRP Report, 2005. No. 71, P. 5.

14. Мартынов И. Э., Маслиев В. Г., Мокроусов С. Д. Износ гребней колес грузовых вагонов и рельсов: проблема и пути ее решения. Вагонний парк. 2013. № 5 (74). С. 4–7.

15. Нормы для расчета и оценки прочности несущих элементов, динамических качеств и воздействия на путь экипажной части локомотивов ж. д. МПС РФ колеи 1520 мм. М.: МПС РФ, ВНИИЖТ, 1998. 145 с.

16. Нормы расчета и оценки прочности несущих элементов и динамических качеств моторвагонного подвижного состава ж. д. МПС РФ колеи 1520 мм. М. : МПС РФ, ВНИИЖТ, 1997. 147 с.

17. Нормы расчета и проектирования вагонов железных дорог МПС колеи 1520 мм (несамоходных) с изменениями. М. : ГосНИИВ-ВНИИЖТ, 1996. 346 с.

18. Вериго М. Ф., Коган А. Я. Об устойчивости движения колеса по рельсу. Вестник ВНИИЖТ. 1965. № 4. С. 3–7.

19. Лукин В. В., Шадур Л. А., Котуронов В. Н., Хохлов А. А. Конструирование и расчет вагонов. М. : 2000. 725 с.

20. Клименко И. В. Развитие теоретических основ и методов оценки и повышения безопасности движения подвижного состава железных дорог: дис. ... д-ра техн. наук: 05.22.07 / Днепропетр. нац. ун-т ж.-д. тр-та им. акад. В. Лазаряна. Днепропетровск, 2015. 284 с.

21. Сокол Э. Н. Сходы с рельсов и столкновения подвижного состава (Судебная экспертиза.Элементы теории и практики). Київ : Транспорт України, 2004. 386 с.





Copyright (c) 2018 Андрій Ярославович Кузишин, Андрій Васильович Батіг

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

All the articles published in ITSSI journal are licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0