The problem of defining moral damage caused to the employee

Authors

  • Olha Panchenko Ph.D in Law, Senior Researcher, Senior Research Fellow of the Department of Scientific and legal expertise and legislative work of the Scientific Institute of Public Law, Ukraine https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4365-0495

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.61345/1339-7915.2023.6.24

Keywords:

court decision, definition, employer, employee, legislation, moral damage

Abstract

Compensation for moral damage is one of the rights guaranteed by the Basic Law of Ukraine; reimbursement of this type of harm is one of the ways to protect labor rights as well. One of the main problems at the moment is the absence of the enshrined concept of moral damage in the Constitution and the Civil Code of Ukraine (this institution is of a civil law nature). Consequently, the aim of the Article is to consider how foreign and domestic scientists approach the term “moral damage” in general and in labor relations in particular and to provide our own definition of this category. The following methods were used when preparing the Article: dialectical, monographic, historical, normative and dogmatic, sociological, legal modeling. Research results. The origin of the term “moral damage” in the world practice and in our country has been investigated. It has been examined, what is moral damage in Ukrainian legislation, as well as in the legal instruments of some other States (Italy, Philippines, El Salvador, Kazakhstan, UAE). The approaches to the concept of moral damage in general and in labor relations in particular have been studied based on the works of foreign and Ukrainian researchers, relevant legal acts of our and other countries, court practice. It has been established that there are three approaches to defining the term of moral (non-property) damage caused to an individual in the theory of civil law. We agree with the opinion by researchers who believe that the fact of establishing moral, mental or physical suffering is not enough – it is necessary to have losses of non-pecuniary nature or negative consequences of a moral or other character. The author’s definition of moral damage as well as moral damage caused to the employee as a result of violation of his (her) labor rights has been proposed.

References

Adamou, M. and Hale, A. (2003) PTSD and the law of psychiatric injury in England and Wales: Finally coming closer? The journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law. No. 31. P. 327 – 332 [in English].

Andrienko, O. (2009) Psychological content of compensation for moral damage in law-making and law- enforcement activities. PhD Dissertation Abstract. Kyiv: Academy of Management of the Ministry of Internal Affairs [in Ukrainian].

Carucci, R. and Praslova, L. (2022) Employees Are Sick of Being Asked to Make Moral Compromises. Harvard Business Review Home. URL: https://hbr.org/2022/02/employees-are-sick-of-being-asked-to-make-moral-compromises [in English].

Case No. UNDT/NBI/2013/016. Gebremariam v. Secretary-General of the United Nations, Judgment on liability and relief of 20 November 2014. URL: https://www.un.org/internaljustice/oaj/sites/default/files/documents/undt-2014-136.pdf [in English].

Case No. UNDT/NBI/2013/036. Toure v. Secretary-General of the United Nations, Judgment on liability and relief of 09 September 2015. URL: https://www.un.org/internaljustice/oaj/sites/default/files/documents/undt-2015-081.pdf [in English].

Chantseva, T. (2018) Problema vyznachennia poniattia «moralna shkoda» [The problem of defining the concept of moral damage]. Zbirnyk Vseukrainskoi naukovo-praktychnoi konferentsii – Collection of the All-Ukrainian Scientific and Practical Conference (pp. 175 – 177). Dnipro: Dnipropetrovsk State University of Internal Affairs [in Ukrainian].

Chernadchuk, V. (2001) Vidshkoduvannia moralnoi shkody pry porushenni trudovykh prav [Compensation for moral damage in violation of labor rights]. PhD Dissertation Abstract. Kyiv: Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv [in Ukrainian].

Decree of the Supreme Council of the Republic of Kazakhstan no. 268-XIII. Civil Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan, December 27, 1994. URL: https://adilet.zan.kz/eng/docs/K940001000_ [in English].

Di Michele laselli (2019) Danno biologico. AltalexPedia, voce agg. al 14/03/2019. URL: https://www.altalex.com/documents/altalexpedia/2013/07/02/danno-biologico [in English].

Federal Law No. 5. On the Civil Transactions Law of the United Arab Emirates, December 15, 1985. URL: https://legaladviceme.com/legislation/126/uae-federal-law-5-of-1985-on-civil-transactions-law-of-united-arab-emirates [in English].

Hryshchuk, O. (2002) Pravo liudyny na kompensatsiiu moralnoi shkody (zahalnoteoretychni aspekty) [The human right to compensation for moral damage (general theoretical aspects)]. PhD Dissertation Abstract. Kyiv: Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv [in Ukrainian].

Kyselyova, O. and Soldatenko, M. (2021) Praktyka vidshkoduvannia moralnoi shkody v trudovomu pravi Ukrainy ta zarubizhnykh krain [The practice of compensation for moral damage in the labor law of Ukraine and foreign countries]. Pravovi horyzonty – Legal horizons. No. 26 (39). P. 59 – 65 [in Ukrainian].

Law of Ukraine No. 254k/96-VR. Konstytutsiia Ukrainy [Constitution of Ukraine]. Ofitsiinyi veb-sait Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy – Official Web site of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, Kyiv, Ukraine, June 28, 1996. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/254%D0%BA/96-%D0%B2%D1%80#Text [in Ukrainian].

Law of Ukraine No. 266/94-VR. Pro poriadok vidshkoduvannia shkody, zavdanoi hromadianynovi nezakonnymy diiamy orhaniv, shcho zdiisniuiut operatyvno-rozshukovu diialnist, orhaniv dosudovoho rozsliduvannia, prokuratury i sudu [On the Procedure for Compensation for Damage Caused to a Citizen by Illegal Actions of the Bodies Conducting Initial Inquiries, Pre-trial Investigation, Procurators’ office and Court]. Ofitsiinyi veb-saitVerkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy – OfficialWeb site of theVerkhovna Rada of Ukraine, Kyiv, Ukraine, December 01, 1994. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/266/94-%D0%B2%D1%80#Text [in Ukrainian].

Law of Ukraine No. 322- VIII. Kodeks zakoniv pro pratsiu Ukrainy [Labor Code of Ukraine]. Ofitsiinyi veb-sait Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy – Official Web site of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, December 10, 1971. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/322-08#Text [in Ukrainian].

Law of Ukraine No. 1618-IV. Tsyvilnyi protsesualnyi kodeks Ukrainy [Civil Procedure Code of Ukraine]. Ofitsiinyi veb-sait Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy – Official Web site of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, March 18, 2004. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1618-15/conv#n9040 [in Ukrainian].

Law of Ukraine No. 959-XII. Pro zovnishnoekonomichnu diialnist [On Foreign Economic Activity]. Ofitsiinyi veb-sait Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy – Official Web site of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, Kyiv, Ukraine, April 16, 1991. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/959-12#Text [in Ukrainian].

Law of Ukraine no. 962-XII. Pro reabilitatsiiu zhertv politychnykh represii na Ukraini [On the Rehabilitation of Victims of Political Repressions in Ukraine]. Ofitsiinyi veb-sait Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy – Official Web site of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, Kyiv, Ukraine, April 17, 1991. https://zakononline.com.ua/documents/show/155627 600097 [in Ukrainian].

Litvinoff, S. (1977) Moral Damages. Louisiana Law Review. No. 38 [in English].

Litz, B. T., Stein, N., Delaney, E., Lebowitz, L., Nash, W. P., Silva, C., Maguen, S. (2009) Moral injury and moral repair in war veterans: A preliminary model and intervention strategy. Clinical Psychology Review. No. 29. P. 695–706 [in English].

Maliuha, L. (2004) Osobysti nemainovi prava fizychnykh osib v tsyvilnomu pravi: teoretychni osnovy ta problemy pravovoho zabezpechennia [Personal non-property rights of individuals in civil law: theoretical foundations and problems of legal protection]. PhD Dissertation. Kyiv: Koretskyi Institute of State and Law of National Academy of Science of Ukraine [in Ukrainian].

Murray, T., Corbin, A. L., Perillo, J. M., Murray, J. E. Jr. (1964). Corbin on Contracts. In 16 volumes, Vol. 11, Part VI “Breach of contract – judicial remedies”. New-York: Matthew Bender [in English].

Onyshchenko, O. (2017) Vidshkoduvannia moralnoi shkody v deliktnykh zoboviazanniakh [Compensation for moral damage in tort liabilities]. PhD Dissertation. Kyiv: National Academy of Internal Affairs of Ukraine [in Ukrainian].

Pavlovska, N. (2002) Teoriia ta praktyka zakhystu moralnykh blah tsyvilnym zakonodavstvom Ukrainy [Theory and practice of protection of moral goods by the civil legislation of Ukraine]. PhD Dissertation Abstract. Kharkiv: National University of Internal Affairs [in Ukrainian].

Rabinovych, P. and Hryshchuk, O. (2003) Pravo osoby na vidshkoduvannia moralnoi shkody [The right of the person to compensation for moral damage]. Biuleten Ministerstva yustytsii Ukrainy – Bulletin of the Ministry of justice of Ukraine. No. 3. P. 19 – 27 [in Ukrainian].

Republic Act No. 386. An act to ordain and institute the civil code of the Philippines. June 18, 1949. URL: https://lawphil.net/statutes/repacts/ra1949/ra_386_1949.html [in English].

Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of Ukraine No. 4. Pro sudovu praktyku v spravakh pro vidshkoduvannia moralnoi (nemainovoi) shkody [On judicial practice in cases of compensation for moral (non-pecuniary) damage]. Ofitsiinyi veb-sait Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy – Official Web site of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, March 31, 1995. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/v0004700-95#Text [in Ukrainian].

Rivas, R. (2019) Moral Damages. Torres Legal. URL: https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=ad96f8ed-66ae-4fa0-8b36-cad0ed137816 [in English].

Selezen, S. (2014) Poniattia vidshkoduvannia moralnoi shkody v trudovomu pravi [The concept of compensation for moral damage in labor law]. Naukovyi visnyk Mizhnarodnoho humanitarnoho universytetu. Seriia: «Iurysprudentsiia» - Scientific Bulletin of the International Humanitarian University. Series: «Jurisprudence». No. 2. P. 21– 23 [in Ukrainian].

Shymon, S. (1998) Vidshkoduvannia moralnoi (nemainovoi) shkody yak sposib zakhystu subiektyvnykh tsyvilnykh prav [Compensation for moral (non-property) damage as a way of protecting subjective civil rights]. PhD Dissertation. Kyiv: Koretskyi Institute of State and Law of National Academy of Science of Ukraine [in Ukrainian].

Sutherland, D. (n.d) Moral injury: What happens when exhausted health workers can no longer provide the care they want for their patients. Victoria University of Wellington. URL: https://amavic.com.au/news---resources/stethoscope/moral-injury-what-happens-when-exhausted-health-workers-can-no-longer-provide-the-care-they-want-for-their-patients [in English].

Stefanchuk, R. (2007) Kompensatsiia moralnoi shkody yak sposib zakhystu osobystykh nemainovykh prav: problemy ta shliakhy vyrishennia [Compensation for moral damage as a way to protect personal non- property rights: problems and solutions]. In: Universytetski naukovi zapysky – University scientific notes. No. 1. P. 67–83 [in Ukrainian].

Svitovenko, D. (2020) Pravovidnosyny iz vidshkoduvannia moralnoi (nemainovoi) shkody v trudovomu pravi: sub’iekty, ob’iekty ta zmist [Legal relations for the compensation of moral (non-property) damage in labor law: subjects, objects and content]. Sotsialne pravo – Social Law. No. 1/2020. P. 189 – 194 [in Ukrainian].

Williamson, V., Murphy, D., Phelps, A., Forbes, D., Greenberg, N. (2021). Moral injury: the effect on mental health and implications for treatment. The Lancet Psychiatry. No. 8 (6). P. 453 – 455. https://doi.org/10.1016/S2215-0366(21)00113-9 [in English].

York, J. (2021). It’s not a burnout. It’s moral injury. Welcome to the Jungle. URL: https://www.welcometothejungle.com/en/articles/burnout-vs-moral-injury [in English].

Downloads

Published

2024-03-14