Analysis of judicial practice on the application of Ukrainian legislation on combating exploitation in the context of armed conflict

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.61345/1339-7915.2023.6.26

Keywords:

human trafficking, child exploitation, law enforcement, portrait of a trafficker

Abstract

The article analyzes the case law on the application of the Criminal Code of Ukraine on combating exploitation in the context of armed conflict. It is noted that the law of Ukraine on criminal liability contains two corpus delicti of criminal offenses relating to exploitation: human trafficking (Article 149) and child exploitation (Article 150 of the Criminal Code), but crime is moving forward and finding other forms of it. Also, in the context of armed conflict, such acts may be qualified under Article 438. Violation of the Laws and Customs of War of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, and law enforcement agencies do not distinguish the category of “human exploitation” separately.

It is concluded that the number of registered criminal offenses under Article 149 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine and convicted persons for human trafficking correlates, in particular, in 2023 as 1:8, and in 2022 – 1:7. It should also be noted that only 56 per cent of the registered criminal offenses under Article 149 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine are sent to court with a guilty verdict. It is noted that child exploitation is characterized by a high level of latency due to unwillingness, and in some cases, unawareness of the unlawful acts committed against the victim (a person under 16 years of age).

It has been established that the typical criminological portrait of a person who has committed human trafficking is as follows: a man (89 per cent) aged 30 to 50 (67 per cent), with a complete secondary or basic secondary education (67 per cent), able-bodied, but who has not worked or studied anywhere (56 per cent), a citizen of Ukraine (72 per cent). This criminal offense is not committed: under the influence of alcohol or drugs; by organized or criminal organizations. Only 28 per cent of criminal offenses under Art. 149 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine are committed as part of a group.

It is noted that the main problems arising in the prosecution of persons who have committed criminal offenses under Art. 149 and Art. 150 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine are the imperfection of the rules, as well as the lack of uniform application in criminal cases of criminal offenses against the will, honor and dignity of a person.

References

Improving protection for victims of forced labour and human trafficking. Strasbourg 12/11/2015. Retrieved from https://www.coe.int/ru/web/commissioner/blog/-/asset_publisher/xZ32OPEoxOkq/content/improving-protection-for-victims-of-forced-labour-and-human- trafficking/pop_up?_com_liferay_asset_publisher_web_portlet_AssetPublisherPortlet_INSTANCE_xZ32OPEoxOkq_languageId=en_GB. [in English].

Kozhen druhyi ukrainets ryzykuie postrazhdaty vid ekspluatatsii cherez spustoshlyvi naslidky viiny [Every second Ukrainian is at risk of exploitation due to the devastating consequences of the war]. Retrieved from https://ukraine.iom.int/uk/news/kozhen-druhyy-ukrayinets-ryzykuye-postrazhdaty-vid-ekspluatatsiyi-cherez-spustoshlyvi-naslidky-viyny [in Ukrainian].

Orlean A.M. (2014) Kryminalno-pravove zabezpechennia okhorony liudyny vid ekspluatatsii [Criminal law ensuring of human being protection against exploitation]. Dysertatsiia d-ra yuryd. nauk 12.00.08 – The thesis for obtaining a doctor of law science degree in speciality 12.00.08. 400. [in Ukrainian].

Myskova G.M. (2020). Kryminalno-pravovi ta kryminolohichni zasady zapobihannia seksualnii ekspluatatsii ditei v Ukraini [Criminal legal and criminological principles to prevent sexual exploitation of children in Ukraine]. Dysertatsiia na zdobuttia naukovoho stupenia doktora filosofii za spetsialnistiu 081 «Pravo» (08 Pravo) - Dissertation for the Doctor of Philosophy degree in specialty 081 “Law” (08 - Law). 232. [in Ukrainian].

Dolyanovskaya I.N. (2008). Kryminalna vidpovidalnist za ekspluatatsiiu ditei (analiz skladu zlochynu) [Criminal Responsibility for Children‘s Exploitation]. Avtoref. dys kand.iuryd. nauk 12.00.08 – Abstract of the diss. ... candidate of law sciences 12.00.08. 18. [in Ukrainian].

Kalmykov D.O. (2008). Kryminalna vidpovidalnist za ekspluatatsiiu ditei [Criminal Liability for Exploitation of Children]. Avtoref. dys. ... kand.iuryd. nauk 12.00.08 – Abstract of the diss. ... candidate of law sciences 12.00.08. 22. [in Ukrainian].

Cockbain Ella, Bowers Kate, Dimitrova Galina. (2018). Human trafficking for labour exploitation: the results of a two-phase systematic review mapping the European evidence base and synthesising key scientific research evidence. Journal of Experimental Criminology. September. Volume 14. Issue 3. Pp. 319-360. [in English].

Oldham JM. (2018) Human Trafficking. Journal of Psychiatr Pract. Mar;24(2):71. doi: 10.1097/PRA.0000000000000289. PMID: 29509175. [in English].

Ukraina – vytiahy iz Dopovidi pro torhivliu liudmy – 2017 rik. Ofitsiinyi sait [Ukraine – excerpts from the Report on human trafficking – 2017. The official website]. Retrieved from https://ua.usembassy.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/151/UKRAINE-2017-TIP-Report-Narrative-Ukr.pdf. [in Ukrainian].

Inspektsiia pratsi informuie: Statystyka shchodo ryzykiv, poviazanykh z torhivleiu liudmy. Ofitsiinyi sait Skhidne mizhrehionalne upravlinnia Derzhavnoi sluzhby Ukrainy z pytan pratsi [The Labor Inspectorate informs: Statistics on the risks associated with human trafficking. The official website of the Eastern Interregional Department of the State Service of Ukraine on Labor Issues]. Retrieved from https://smu.dsp.gov.ua/news/inspektsiia-pratsi-informuie-statystyka-shchodo-ryzykiv-pov-iazanykh-z-torhivleiu-liudmy/. [in Ukrainian].

Sozanskyi T.I., Hazdaika-Vasylyshyn I.B. , Mruchkovska E.M. , Shekhavtsov R.M. (2019). Osoblyvosti kvalifikatsii ta rozsliduvannia zlochyniv, poviazanykh z torhivleiu liudmy ta nezakonnoiu mihratsiieiu [Peculiarities of qualification and investigation of crimes related to human trafficking and illegal migration]. 252. [in Ukrainian].

Panchuk O.V. (2008). Kryminolohichna kharakterystyka ekspluatatsii ditei [Criminological Characteristic of Children’s Exploitation]. Avtoref. dys. ... kand.iuryd. nauk 12.00.08 – Abstract of the diss. ... candidate of law sciences 12.00.08. 27. [in Ukrainian].

Rymskyi statut Mizhnarodnoho kryminalnoho sudu 1998 roku [Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court] Retrieved from https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/995_588#Text/. [in Ukrainian].

Downloads

Published

2024-03-14