Genocide in Ukraine: problems of proof

Authors

  • Olena Garsymiv Candidate of Law Sciences, Associate Professor, Associate Professor, Department of Criminal Procedure and Criminalistics, Lviv State University of Internal Affairs, Ukraine https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4588-9531
  • Serhiy Marko Candidate of Law Sciences, Associate Professor., Associate Professor, Department of Criminal Procedure and Criminalistics, Lviv State University of Internal Affairs, Ukraine https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9778-0570
  • Olena Ryashko Candidate of Law Sciences, Associate Professor., Associate Professor, Department of Criminal Procedure and Criminalistics, Lviv State University of Internal Affairs, Ukraine

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.61345/1339-7915.2024.1.3

Keywords:

genocide, investigation, evidence, destruction, intent

Abstract

The article emphasizes that genocide was first criminalized immediately after the Second World War, precisely in 1948 when the UN General Assembly unanimously adopted the Convention on the Prevention of Genocide. In terms of severity, it is undoubtedly the most serious crime for both peacetime and wartime, and it is also the most difficult to prove. First of all, it is argued that in order to establish the very fact of genocide, it is necessary to have the intention to destroy, in whole or in part, any national, ethnic, racial or religious group, as well as for this destruction to be carried out by killing, inflicting grievous injuries, creating intolerable conditions life, prevention of childbirth or forced transfer of children to another group.

The main focus of the article is on the fact that crimes against humanity most often occur during war. In order for the underlying crimes—such as murder, torture, extermination, sexual violence, and other acts—to qualify as crimes against humanity, they must be part of a widespread or systematic attack on civilians. Unfortunately, trials for genocide and crimes against humanity take forever. An example is the events in Srebrenica, proceedings in several genocide cases are still ongoing. Genocide, as well as crimes against humanity, are most clearly defined in legal terms in the Rome Statute of 1998, which became the foundational document of the International Criminal Court.

Both crimes were also included in the criminal codes of many countries, the Criminal Code of Ukraine (Articles 442, 437) was not an exception. However, until now, there is no responsibility for crimes against humanity in national legislation. Therefore, currently the criminal actions of the combatants can only be qualified as war crimes. Many states have integrated the crime of genocide into national legislation, but not all have used the UN definition. Many states have also included crimes against humanity in their criminal codes. It is quite clear that both genocide and crimes against humanity are systematic crimes, to prove which it is not enough to confirm with evidence the commission of individual acts.

Both crimes are committed within a system, often wide-ranging, and both contain elements that require proof of relevant intent or awareness on the part of the perpetrators, for example, in the case of genocide, by proving that the perpetrators knew of an express or implied plan.

References

Rebrish R.I. Genocide as a crime against the security of humanity under international criminal law. Scientific Bulletin of the Uzhhorod National University, 2016. P. 127–129.

M.M. Gerasimenko. Peculiarities of genocide investigation. Journal of the Kyiv University of Law. 2020/2. P. 398–401

Makarenkov O.L. Verification of war crimes committed in Ukraine by instruments of international criminal law. Law and society. No. 1/2023. P. 380–388.

Ivchuk Yu.Yu. The concept of “genocide” as an international crime and the peculiarities of prosecution in the light of the armed aggression of the Russian Federation against Ukraine. Legal scientific electronic journal. No. 4/2023. P. 685–687.

Krasnikova O.V. Signs of the genocide of the Ukrainian people during the modern war between Ukraine and Russia. Legal scientific electronic journal. No. 5/2023. P. 409–412.

Gerasimenko M.M., Hovpun O.S. Criminal and legal characteristics of genocide: global practice of determining the number of victims. BULLETIN OF THE PENITENTIARY ASSOCIATION OF UKRAINE. 2021 / No. 2(16). P. 52–63.

Jonathan Leader Maynard. Is there genocide in Ukraine? An expert’s explanation of indicators and assessments. April 6, 2020 https://www.justsecurity.org/81015/is-genocide-occurring-in-ukraine-an-expert-explainer-on-indicators-and-assessments-ua.

Olesya Gontar, Nadia Mikievych. 10 main questions about genocide in Ukraine, its punishment and international courts https://www.eurointegration.com.ua/articles/2022/05/20/7139730.

Onisia Sinyuk. What is the crime of genocide, how to prove it and whether there are signs of the genocide of Ukrainians. https://zmina.info/instructions/shho-take-zlochyn-genoczydu-yak-jogo-dovesty-i-chy-ye-oznaky-genoczydu-ukrayincziv.

Natalia Zinevych. To the issue of the specifics of the genocide of Roma on Ukrainian lands during the Second World War. THE HOLOCAUST AND THE PRESENT TIME. No. 2 (6) 2009. P. 148–163.

Downloads

Published

2024-05-06