On the implementation and functioning of the «Barnahus»

Authors

  • Natalia Kalyniuk PhD of Law, Associate Professor, Associate Professor of the Department of Higher Educational Pedagogy and Social Sciences, «I. Horbachevsky Ternopil National Medical University», Ukraine https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1613-835X
  • Nadiia Humenna PhD of Law, Associate Professor, Associate Professor of the Department of Higher Educational Pedagogy and Social Sciences, «I. Horbachevsky Ternopil National Medical University», Ukraine https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3838-3858

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.61345/1339-7915.2024.1.4

Keywords:

child victims, child witnesses, Barnahus model, quality standards, legal system, European experience, Barnahus centers

Abstract

The aim of the work is to study and analyze the Barnahus model through the prism of European experience and the legal system of Ukraine.

The methodological basis of the study is the dialectical method of scientific knowledge, since the genesis of the «Barnachus» model was revealed with its help. From the standpoint of the value approach, legal ideas, the normative legal framework and law enforcement practice were investigated. The work uses such general scientific methods as: system analysis, ascent from the general to the specific, analogy, generalization, comparison, as well as the principle of historicism, social and objective approach, which contributed to the disclosure of the features of the «Barnachus» model as a whole and its components, in particular. Special-legal methods, such as comparative- legal, formal-dogmatic, sociological-legal, cultural-legal.

Results. The article is devoted to the Barnahus model, which is currently an innovative model at the European level in the field of combating violence against children and child-friendly justice. Ukraine, striving to become a full-fledged member of the European Union, has undertaken a number of obligations, including to provide children with additional procedural guarantees during their interrogation (questioning) in criminal proceedings. The article examines and analyzes the Barnahus model through the prism of European experience and the legal system of Ukraine. The author analyzes the basic ideas of the Barnahus model; examines the peculiarities of the formation and development of the Barnahus model in the legal systems of Scandinavian countries; clarifies the European quality standards of the Barnahus model as a result of the PROMISE network; examines the organizational and legal framework for the implementation and functioning of the Barnahus model in Ukraine; analyzes the impact of national legislation on the functioning of the Barnahus model in Ukraine, revealing certain problematic aspects.

Conclusion. It is established that the Barnahus model is a multidisciplinary program for child victims and child witnesses of violence or cruelty, organized in a child-friendly environment and under one roof to ensure effective protection, quick access to justice, and the provision of necessary services. It is proved that its main task is to cooperate «under one roof» of an interagency and interdisciplinary team involved in juvenile criminal justice for effective coordinated work (collecting evidence, providing services, creating a child-friendly environment, helping to return to their usual life, etc.) and achieving maximum interaction with child witnesses or child victims of violence or cruelty.

References

Combating violence against children in Ukraine - Phase II. (2021) Legal analysis of the operation of the «Barnachus» model in Ukraine. © Council of Europe office in Ukraine. 2021. 62 c. [in English].

Emelie Ernberg, Mikaela Magnusson, Linnea Koponen, Sara Landström. (2022) «It doesn’t work at all, that’s my experience»: Swedish forensic interviewers’ views on interpreter-mediated child interviews. Child Abuse & Neglect. Volume 127. 2022. 105540., ISSN 0145-2134, https://doi.org/10.1016/j. chiabu.2022.105540 [in English].

Lopushanska Olga. (2022) Implementation of the Barnahus model for the protection of child victims of violence. URL: https://www.healthright.org.ua/proekti/barnahus/ [in English].

Memorandum pro vzayemorozuminnya mizh Upovnovazhenym Verkhovnoyi Rady Ukrayiny z prav lyudyny, Upovnovazhenym Prezydenta Ukrayiny z prav dytyny, Verkhovnym Sudom, Ofisom Heneral’noho prokurora, Ministerstvom yustytsiyi Ukrayiny, Ministerstvom vnutrishnikh sprav Ukrayiny, Ministerstvom sotsial’noyi polityky Ukrayiny, Ministerstvom okhorony zdorovʺya Ukrayiny, Natsional’noyu politsiyeyu Ukrayiny, Koordynatsiynym tsentrom z nadannya pravovoyi dopomohy ta Predstavnytstvom Dytyachoho fondu OON (YUNISEF) v Ukrayini z pytan’ spryyannya vprovadzhennyu modeli Barnakhus v Ukrayini vid 17.08.2021. (2021) URL: https://www.legalaid.gov.ua/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/bagatostoronnij-memorandum-barnahus.pdf (data to access: 27.12.2023) [in Ukrainian].

Mitchell, M., Lundy, L., & Hill, L. (2023) Children’s human rights to ‘participation’ and ‘protection’: Rethinking the relationship using Barnahus as a case example. Child Abuse Review, 32(6), Article e2820. https://doi.org/10.1002/car.2820 [in English].

MODEL’ «BARNAKHUS» (2021): Zahal’na kharakterystyka i vprovadzhennya v Ukrayini. Zbirka materialiv iz vprovadzhennya modeli «Barnakhus» v Ukrayini. Dovidkove vydannya. Seriya materialiv iz vprovadzhennya modeli «Barnakhus» v Ukrayini. 52 p. [in Ukrainian].

Pereda, N., Bartolomé, M., & Rivas, E. (2021) Revisión del Modelo Barnahus: ¿Es posible evitar la victimización secundaria en el testimonio infantil?. Boletín Criminológico, (27). https://doi. org/10.24310/Boletin-criminologico.2021.v28i.12377 [in English].

Pro nevidkladni zakhody iz zapobihannya ta protydiyi domashn’omu nasyl’stvu, nasyl’stvu za oznakoyu stati, zakhystu prav osib, yaki postrazhdaly vid takoho nasyl’stva (2020): Ukaz Prezydenta Ukrayiny № 398/2020 vid 21.09.2020. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/398/2020#Text (date to access: 17.03.2024) [in Ukrainian].

Pro skhvalennya Natsional’noyi stratehiyi reformuvannya systemy yustytsiyi shchodo ditey na period do 2023 roku (2018): Rozporyadzhennya Kabinetu Ministriv Ukrayiny vid 18.12.2018. № 1027-r. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1027-2018-%D1%80#Text (date to access: 20.03.2024) [in Ukrainian].

PROMISE Barnahus Network Stratedy 2020-2025. (2020) URL: https://www.barnahus.eu/en/about-us/ (date to access: 23.02.2024) [in English]..

Susanna Johansson & Kari Stefansen. (2019) Policy-making for the diffusion of socialinnovations: the case of the Barnahus modelin the Nordic region and the broader Europeancontext. Innovation The Europian Journal of Social Science, nj 33(1): 1-17 DOI: 10.1080/13511610.2019.1598255 [in English].

UN Commission on Human Rights (46th sess : 1990 : Geneva), Convention on the Rights of the Child., E/ CN.4/RES/1990/74, UN Commission on Human Rights, 7 March 1990, https://www.refworld.org/legal/resolution/unchr/1990/en/47325 (date to access: 16.03.2024) [in English].

Valentyn V. Franchuk, Mykhailo S. Myroshnychenko, Mykhajlo S. Hnatjuk, Natalia M. Kalyniuk, Nadiia V. Humenna, Anna V. Narizhna, Ulyana Ya. Franchuk, Olena I. Hladii, Maksym V. Franchuk. (2023) Implementation of the decision tree method in expert analysis of the medical errors in obstetric practice. Polish medical journal. 2023. Volume LI. Issue 2. Mar-Apr. P. 128-134 [in English].

Zasul’s’ka Mariya. (2023) Zaprovadzhennya modeli «Barnakhus» v Ukrayini ta mizhnarodnyy dosvid. URL: https://medconstructor.org/analytics/zaprovadzhennya-modeli-barnaxus-v-ukrayini-ta-mizhnarodnij-dosvid/ (to access: 28.02.2024) [in English].

Downloads

Published

2024-05-06