Ukrainian revolution and the problem of creation national parliament

Authors

  • Valerii Soldatenko I. F. Kuras Institute of Political and Ethnic Studies of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, Ukraine

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.15587/2523-4153.2017.111792

Keywords:

Ukrainian revolution, the state, democracy, Parliament, parliamentary, Constituent, National Assembly, the Sejm

Abstract

In this article, based on the analysis of available documents and real historical facts was made an attempt to follow the approaches and practices of the political forces that sought to implement the concept of the Ukrainian national-democratic revolution, one of its core program requirements - the convening of a national parliament.

First steps in the aforementioned direction were made during the time of the Central Rada, headed by M. Hrushevsky. Leading political coordination center, created on a democratic basis and, in the conviction of its leaders, called upon to bring the Ukrainian community into a national system, in the process of its development began to take on some of the functions inherent in the classical examples of the world, first of all European parliamentarism. Starting from the documents of the Ukrainian National Congress (April 6-8, 1917, Kiev), Ukrainian political parties, and the approval of the Constitution of the Ukrainian People's Republic (April 29, 1918), due to the convening of a parliamentary institution (the names were different - Ukrainian Constituent Assembly, The Constituent Council, the Ukrainian Sejm (Soim), the Legislative Duma, the Provisional Parliamentary Assembly, the Parliament, the National Assembly of Ukraine, etc.) the task of creating the People's Parliament was put forward as a political perspective. The same Central Rada, or its unchanging Chairman, or scholars of law, constitutionalists, guided by scientific criteria, are not inclined to qualify as a full-fledged National Parliament. And the initiated process of movement in a democratic way was the force interrupted by the coup on April 29, 1918.

Upon coming to power, hetman P. Skoropadsky abolished the Constitution of the UPR with his first acts and banned the convening of the Constituent Assembly, which planned to convene the Central Rada.

In times of Hetmanate temporality, extraordinary, transient impetus of authoritarian rule were proved in every way. Numerous public declarations promised to create a parliamentary institution (for 7,5 months of the official existence of the Ukrainian State, even its name was not tired) have in fact turned out to be an empty sound. But the real position of delaying the authorities to resolve the popular, urgent problem was rigorously co-ordinated with the Austro-German occupation administration, for which, as the true ruler of the situation in the country, the National Parliament seemed unclear, totally unnecessary rage.

On the business ground, the Directory tried to implement of the idea of creating a national parliament. However, the general situation of 1919 - 1920 was overcomplicated. In particular, contradictions in the political direction of the revived Ukrainian People's Republic were significantly negative. For some time it was planned to delegate the role of the Parliament before the Labor Congress of Ukraine (January 23-29, 1919), but it did not become, according to the plan, a permanent institution. Practically performing certain parliamentary functions (for example, lawmaking activities), the Directory, like the Central Rada, planned to convene a full-fledged national parliament, eventually determined by the beginning of implementation of the judicial process (Act of Unification of the UNR and ZUNR on January 22, 1919). However, due to the difficult, first of all the military, situation which permanently deteriorated, the realization of democratic state-building plans did not happen.

Thus, in spite of ideas, initiatives, plans, preparatory efforts and approved documents, the practice of fulfilling some of the functions inherent in the Parliament, such a genuine institution in the revolutionary era (1917-1920), was not created in Ukraine.

Author Biography

Valerii Soldatenko, I. F. Kuras Institute of Political and Ethnic Studies of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine

Corresponding Member of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, Doctor of Historical Sciences, Professor, Chief Scientist

References

  1. Holos Ukrainy (2017). Hazeta, No. 50.
  2. «Vidlunnia zolotoho homonu». Holos Ukrainy (2017). Hazeta, No. 49.
  3. Ukrainska Tsentralna Rada. Dokumenty i materialy. Vol. 1 (1996). Kyiv, 591.
  4. Ukrainskyi natsionalno-vyzvolnyi rukh. Berezen – lystopad 1917 roku: Dokumenty i materialy (2003). Kyiv, 1024.
  5. Dyrektoriia, Rada Narodnykh Ministriv Ukrainskoi Narodnoi Respubliky. Lystopad 1918 – lystopad 1920. Vol. 1., Vol. 2 (2006). Kyiv: Vydavnytstvo imeni Oleny Telihy, 688, 744.
  6. Ukrainska Derzhava (kviten-hruden 1918 roku). Dokumenty i materialy. Vol. 1., Vol. 2 (2015). Kyiv, 790, 412.
  7. Ukrainska revoliutsiia i derzhavnist (1917–1920 rr.) (1998). Kyiv, 248.
  8. Soldatenko, V. F. (1999). Ukrainska revoliutsiia. Istorychnyi narys. Kyiv, 976.
  9. Politychna istoriia Ukrainy. XX stolittia. Vol. 2. Revoliutsyi v Ukraini: polityko-derzhavni modeli ta realii (1917–1920) (2002). Kyiv, 488.
  10. Ukraina: politychna istoriia. XX – pochatok XXI st. (2007). Kyiv, 225–432.
  11. Ukrainskyi vybir: politychni systemy XX stolittia i poshuk vlasnoi modeli suspilnoho rozvytku (2007). Kyiv, 107–299.
  12. Sotsialno-politychni transformatsyi v Ukraini: vid zadumiv do realyi (2009). Kyiv, 116–296.
  13. Soldatenko, V. F., Liubovets, O. M. (2010). Revoliutsiini alternatyvy 1917 roku y Ukraina. Kyiv, 320.
  14. Soldatenko, V. F. (2011). Proekt «Ukraina» 1917–1920 rr. Postati. Kharkiv, 511.
  15. Narysy istoryi Ukrainskoi revoliutsyi 1917–1921 rokiv. Kn. 1, Kn. 2 (2011–2012). Kyiv, 390, 464.
  16. Ukrainska revoliutsiya 1917–1921 rokiv: pohliad iz sohodennia (2013). Kyiv, 656.
  17. Ukrainska revoliutsiia i derzhavnist (1917–1920 rr.) (2001). Kyiv, 816.
  18. Kapeliushnyi, V. P. (2003). Zdobuta i vtrachena nezalezhnist: istoriohrafichnyi narys ukrainskoi derzhavnosti doby natsionalno-vyzvolnykh zmahan (1917–1921 rr.). Kyiv, 495.
  19. Kopylenko, O. L., Kopylenko, M. L. (1997). Derzhava i pravo Ukrainy 1917–1920. Kyiv, 208.
  20. Myronenko, O. M. (2002). Vytoky ukrainskoho revoliutsiinoho konstytutsionalizmu 1917–1920 rr.: teoretyko-metodolohichnyi aspekt. Kyiv, 260.
  21. Holovchenko, V. (2007). Ukrainska Narodna Respublika v konteksti hlobalnoi «pershoi khvyli demokratyzatsyi». Ukraina v revoliutsiynykh protsesakh pershykh desiatylit XX stolittia. Kyiv, 98–109.
  22. Kopylenko, O. (2008). Problema pravotvorennia Ukrainskoi revoliutsyi. Ukraina v revoliutsiynykh protsesakh pershykh desiatylit XX stolittia. Mizhnarodna naukovo-teoretychna konferentsiya 20-21 lystopada 2007 r. Naukovi doslidzhennia. Kyiv, 24–48.
  23. Shemshuchenko, Yu. (2008). Uroky konstytutsiynoho budivnytstva v Ukrainskyi Narodnii Respublitsi. Ukraina v revoliutsiynykh protsesakh pershykh desiatylit XX stolittia. Mizhnarodna naukovo-teoretychna konferentsiya 20-21 lystopada 2007 r. Naukovi doslidzhennia. Kyiv, 49–56.
  24. Pyrih, R. Ya. (2008). Hetmanat Pavla Skoropadskoho: sutnist i forma derzhavnosti. Hetmanat Pavla Skoropadskoho: istoriya, pohliady, kontroversiy: Vseukrainska naukova konferentsiya 19-20 travnia 2008 r. Kyiv, 6–12.
  25. Tereshchenko, Yu. I. (2008). Hetmanat Pavla Skoropadskoho yak proiav konservatyvnoi revoliutsiy. Hetmanat Pavla Skoropadskoho: istoriya, pohliady, kontroversiy: Vseukrainska naukova konferentsiya 19-20 travnia 2008 r. Kyiv, 13–40.
  26. Ivanova, A. Yu. (2011). Zakonodavchyi protses i zakonodavcha tekhnika v period Tsentralnoi Rady, Hetmanatu P. P. Skoropadskoho ta Dyrektoryi. Kyiv, 224.
  27. Tomenko, M. (2012). Parlamentaryzm v Ukraini: istorychne yavyshche i naukova problema. Ukrainskyi parlamentaryzm: problemy istorii ta suchasnoi politychnoi praktyky (do 145-richchia vid dnia narodzhennia Mykhaila Hrushevskoho). Kyiv, 18–21.
  28. Soldatenko, V. (2012). Mykhailo Hrushevskyi i Tsentralna Rada: parlamentski iliuzyi i realyi. Ukrainskyi parlamentaryzm: problemy istorii ta suchasnoi politychnoi praktyky (do 145-richchia vid dnia narodzhennia Mykhaila Hrushevskoho). Kyiv, 22–36.
  29. Shemshuchenko, Yu. S. (2012). Konstytutsiyni idei M. S. Hrushevskoho i suchasnist. Ukrainskyi parlamentaryzm: problemy istoryi ta suchasnoi politychnoi praktyky (do 145-richchia vid dnia narodzhennia Mykhaila Hrushevskoho). Kyiv, 54–58.
  30. Kopylenko, O. (2012). Problemy pravotvorennia v pershomu Ukrainskomu parlamenti. Ukrainskyi parlamentaryzm: problemy istoryi ta suchasnoi politychnoi praktyky (do 145-richchia vid dnia narodzhennia Mykhaila Hrushevskoho). Kyiv, 59–73.
  31. Pyrih, R. Ya. (2012). Problema vyboriv do seimu u vnutrishniy politytsi Hetmanatu P. Skoropadskoho (kviten-hruden 1918 r.). Ukrainskyi istorychnyi zhurnal, 3, 28–35.
  32. Shveda, Yu. (2011). Parlament. Politychna entsyklopediya. Kyiv, 535–539.
  33. Romaniuk, A. (2011). Parlamentaryzm. Politychna entsyklopediya. Kyiv, 539.
  34. Shapoval, V. M. (2002). Parlament. Parlamentaryzm. Vol. 4. Yurydychna entsyklopediya. Kyiv, 434–436.
  35. Hrushevskyi, M. S. (1992). Khto taki ukraintsi i choho vony khochut. Velykyi Ukrainets. Materialy z zhyttia ta diialnosti M. Hrushevskoho. Kyiv, 70.
  36. Nova Rada (Kyiv) (1917). 25 bereznia.
  37. Robitnycha hazeta (Kyiv) (1917). 6 kvitnia.
  38. Khrystiuk, P. (1921). Zamitky i materialy do istoryi Ukrainskoi revoliutsyi. Vol. I. Praha, 36.
  39. Ukrainski politychni partyi kintsia XX – pochatku XX stolittia: Prohramovi i dovidkovi materialy (1993). Kyiv, 121.
  40. Liubovets, O. M. (2012). Ukrainski partiy revoliutsiynoi doby. Kyiv, 234, 257, 322.
  41. Khmil, I. V. (1989). Na shliakhu vidrodzhennia ukrainskoi derzhavnosti (Ukrainskyi natsionalnyi konhres-zizd 6-8 kvitnia 1917 r.). Kyiv, 32–44.
  42. Hrushevskyi, M. (1988). Spomyny. Kyiv, 9, 122–123.
  43. Shapoval, V. M. (2002). Parlamentaryzm. Vol. 4. Kyiv: Vydavnytstvo «Ukrain ska entsyklopediya» im. M. P. Bazhana, 435.
  44. Khrystiuk, P. (1921). Zamitky i materialy do istoryi Ukrainskoi revoliutsyi. Vol. II. Praha, 86.
  45. Soldatenko, V. F. (2010). Ukraina v revoliutsiynu dobu: Istorychni ese-khroniky. Vol. I. Rik 1917. Kyiv: Svitohliad, 280–289.
  46. Bevz, T. A. (2008). Partiya natsionalnykh interesiv i sotsialnykh perspektyv (Politychna istoriya UPSR). Kyiv, 283–285.
  47. Visti z Ukrainskoi Tsentralnoi Rady (1917). No. 22-23.
  48. Nova Rada (1917). 12 zhovtnia.
  49. Nova Rada (1917). 8 lystopada.
  50. Konfederalist (Kyiv) (1917). 5 lystopada.
  51. Konfederalist (Kyiv) (1917). 12 lystopada.
  52. Maievskyi, Y. (1917). Zahalnorosiyski Ustanovchi Zbory. Kyiv, 7.
  53. Ukrainska Tsentralna Rada. Dokumenty i materialy. Vol. 2 (1997). Kyiv, 424.
  54. Hrushevskyi, M. (1991). Na porozi Novoi Ukrainy: Hadky i mriy. Kyiv, 86–88.
  55. Hrushevskyi, M. (1992). Na porozi Novoi Ukrainy. Statti i dzherelni materialy. Niu-York; Lviv; Kyiv; Toronto; Miunkhen, 278.
  56. Robitnycha hazeta (Kyiv) (1918). 14 kvitnia.
  57. Konstytutsiyni akty Ukrainy 1917–1920: Nevidomi Konstytutsyi Ukrainy (1992). Kyiv, 82.
  58. Chekhovych, V. A. (1999). Dyrektoriya UNR. Vol. 2. Yurydychna entsyklopediya. Kyiv, 191.
  59. Soldatenko, V. F. (2009). Ukraina v revoliutsiynu dobu. Istorychni ese-khroniky. Vol. II. Kyiv, 349–357.
  60. Vynnychenko, V. Vidrodzhennia natsyi (Istoriya ukrainskoi revoliutsyi [marets 1917 – hruden 1919]). Ch. III (1920). Kyiv-Viden, 170–176.
  61. Khrystiuk, P. (1922). Zamitky i materialy do istoryi ukrainskoi revoliutsyi. Vol. IV. Praha, 19.
  62. Soldatenko, V. F. (2010). Ukraina v revoliutsiynu dobu. Istorychni ese-khroniky. Vol. III. Rik 1919. Kyiv, 9–24, 42–43.
  63. Soldatenko, V. F. (2007). Vynnychenko i Petliura: politychni portrety revoliutsiinoi doby. Kyiv, 254–297.
  64. Lozynskyi. Halychyna v rr. 1918–1920 (1922). Praha, 67–71.
  65. Shapoval, M. Velyka revoliutsiya y ukrainska vyzvolna prohrama (1928). Praha, 127–129.
  66. Mazepa, I. (1942). Ukraina v ohni y buri revoliutsyi. Vol. I. Praha, 87.
  67. Soldatenko, V. F. (2011). S. Petliura i otamanshchyna. Revoliutsiyna doba v Ukraini (1917–1920 rr.): lohika piznannia, istorychni postati, kliuchovi epizody. Kyiv, 259–309.
  68. Soldatenko, V. F. (2016). Rezhym otamanshchyny v UNR 1919 r.: vytoky, sutnist, naslidky. Hileia. Naukovyi visnyk, 113, 46–60.
  69. Mytrofanenko, Yu. (2016). Ukrainska otamanshchyna 1918–1919 rokiv. Kyiv, 238.
  70. Mazepa, I. (1942). Ukraina v ohni y buri revoliutsyi 1917–1921. Vol. 2. Praha, 636–637.
  71. Vistnyk Derzhavnykh zakoniv dlia vsikh zemel UNR (1919). 2.
  72. Shelukhyn, S. P. (1922). Petliurivtsi v svitli prava. Lviv-Viden, 10–11.
  73. Syvolob, Yu. V. (1993). Teoretyk ukrainskoi derzhavnosti (Stanislav Dnistrianskyi). Ukrainska ideia. Postati na tli revoliutsyi. Kyiv, 228–231.
  74. Myronenko, O. M. (2002). Vytoky ukrainskoho revoliutsiynoho kon­sty­tutsionalizmu 1917–1920 rr.: Teoretyko-metodolohichnyi aspekt. Kyiv: In-t derzhavy i prava im. V. M. Koretskoho NAN Ukrainy, 260.

Published

2017-09-30

How to Cite

Soldatenko, V. (2017). Ukrainian revolution and the problem of creation national parliament. ScienceRise: Juridical Science, (1 (1), 5–18. https://doi.org/10.15587/2523-4153.2017.111792

Issue

Section

Juridical Science