• Adel Shamsiev
  • Shamsiev Babin



Abstract. The article highlights the competitive advantages of educational program network form. The authors emphasize that the information openness of a university stimulates the development of both internal and external competitive environments due to the availability of system management knowledge about the basic processes and the openness of academic knowledge located in the academic portfolio. The purpose of the article is to develop the system of qualitative and quantitative indicators of educational service digitalization. The article analyzes and synthesizes the areas of educational service digitalization in Russian universities, and the materials of scientific publications. They set
out the modern features of university informatization. Based on the principles of knowledge management, they formulated the goals of a university network information environment development. They proposed the system of qualitative and quantitative indicators of educational service digitalization. By the means of expert assessments qualitative indicators measure transparency, convergence, modifiability, integrativity, progressiveness, coevolution, adaptability, competitiveness, productivity, competitiveness and competence. In the context of groups quantitative indicators (resource, process, result) can be used to calculate the composite integral indicator of educational service
digitization and the analysis of innovation efficiency in the "resource-processes-results" model. One of the possible trends of future research may be the measurement of the economic efficiency concerning educational service digitalization.
Keywords: educational services, university, innovation, knowledge management, network information
environment, competitive advantage, indicator, digitalization, digital transformation, electronic information educational environment.


Lester, M. “Innovation and knowledge management: The long view”, Creativity and Innovation Management,

(3), pp. 165-176, 2001.

Fernández Hernández, A. “Information framework of intranet portal: An essential component in the information

management at the universities | [Arquitectura de información de los portales intranets: Un componente esencial de la

gestión de información en las universidades]”, ACIMED, 19(4), 2009.

Ivanova, V., Mertins, K., Alexandrova, M., Baranov, P. “Soft skills and moodle”, MATEC Web of Conferences,

, 01056, 2017.

Bogdanova, M. “Cognitive science: From multidisciplinarity to interdisciplinarity”, International Journal of

Cognitive Research in Science, Engineering and Education, 5(2), pp. 145-150, 2017.

Borba, M.C., Chiari, A.S.S., de Almeida, H.R.F.L. “Interactions in virtual learning environments: new roles for

digital technology”, Educational Studies in Mathematics, 98(3), pp. 269-286, 2018. .

Yolkin, I.V., Babin E.N. «Тhe model of managerial knowledge of a Higher Education Institution within network

environment» , Revista Publicando, V.4, No 13. (1), pp. 1057-1072., 2017.

. Reikhanova, I.V., Bukina, Y.V. “Optimization of educational services management in Russia for provision of

succession of all levels of education with the help of new information and communication technologies”, Advances in

Intelligent Systems and Computing, 726, pp. 957-963, 2019.

Vega-Hernández, M.-C., Patino-Alonso, M.-C., Galindo-Villardón, M.-P. “Multivariate characterization of

university students using the ICT for learning”, Computers and Education, 121, pp. 124-130, 2018.

Gutiérrez-Porlán, I., Román-García, M., Sánchez-Vera, M.-M. “Strategies for the communication and

collaborative online work by university students”, Comunicar, 26(54), pp. 91-99, 2018.

Nonaka I., Takeuchi H. The knowledge creating company: how Japanese companies create the dynamics of

innovation, Oxford University Press, New York, NY.1995.

Kadochnikova E. I., Ismigilov I. I. “Measurement of cognitive growth factors of regional economy based on

panel data “, Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences, 5 (24), pp. 377-382, 2014.

Konina, O.V., Nanetadze, E.D. “Managing a modern university: The role of business processes in the structure

of establishments of higher professional education”, Advances in Intelligent Systems and Computing, 726, с. 1053-1059,