S. Prokofyev's ballet The Jester on the Kyiv stage in the optics of art criticism

Authors

  • Alina Pidlypska

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.32461/2226-3209.3.2020.220118

Keywords:

ballet The Jester, Sergei Prokofiev, ballet critic, Kiev Opera and Ballet Theater.

Abstract

The purpose of the research is to reveal the artistic features of the production of S. Prokofiev's ballet The Jester (1928) on the Kiev stage through the prism of the then critical discourse. Methodology. The analysis (for understanding the reviews of the ballet The Jester), comparison (for comparing the positions of the reviewers), the historical approach (for conducting the research in chronological order) are applied. The scientific novelt. The scientific novelty lies in the reproduction of the artistic critical discourse of S. Prokofiev's ballet The Jester (1928) in Ukraine; the introduction of new materials into scientific circulation, which significantly expand the understanding not only of the named ballet, but also of approaches to the artistic evaluation of ballet performances in the late 1920s. in the Ukrainian SSR. Conclusions. The production of S. Prokofiev's ballet The Jester (1928, choreographer M. Diskovsky) on the stage of the Kiev State Academic Opera caused a wide resonance in the artistic periodicals of Ukraine (the magazines Soviet Art, New Art, etc.). Most of the attention is paid to the musical score; a wide range of assessments is presented from extremely negative to unquestioning recognition of the novelty of music. The very exact correspondence of pantomime plastics to the nuances of music was positively assessed. The ballet is accused of formalism, the absence of proper choreographic means of expressiveness, the dominance of pantomime, and lack of focus on the mass audience. At the same time, his progressiveness is noted due to the rejection of academic ballet vocabulary, the search for new means of expression.

References

Asaf'ev, B. (1974). "The Tale of the Jester of the Seven Jesters who joked". Asaf'ev, B. (1974). About ballet: articles, reviews, memoirs. Leningrad: Music, 97–102 [in Russian].

Birskaja, L. (2011). Prokofiev. "The Tale of the Jester ...". South-Russian Musical Almanac, 48–49 [in Russian].

Verykivskyi, M. (1928). Prokofiev's The Jester production. Soviet art, 4, 5–6 [in Ukrainian].

Voronyi, M. (1928). About S. Prokofiev's The Jester. Soviet art, 4, 7 [in Ukrainian].

Gvozdev, A. (1927, April 28). The Ice Maiden (Academic Ballet). Red newspaper: evening edition [in Russian].

Hrudin, V. (1928). About the repertoire of our opera. Soviet art, 11, 7–8 [in Ukrainian].

Dyskovskyi, M. (1928). "Criticism of critics." Soviet art, 6, 8–9 [in Ukrainian].

Dolinskaja, E. (2012). Prokofiev Theater. Moscow: Composer [in Russian].

Ernst, F. (1928). The production of The Jester at the Kyiv Opera. Soviet art, 4, 7 [in Ukrainian].

Zolotarov, Yu. (1928). Music pins. Soviet art, 4, 4–5 [in Ukrainian].

Zolotarov, Yu. (1928). On the way to renewal. Soviet art, 10, 4–5 [in Ukrainian].

Korotina, A. (2016). Author's claviers of S. S. Prokofiev 1911–1934: the history of creation and some features of the composer's creative work. Bulletin of the Kemerovo State University of Culture and Arts, 34, 48–56 [in Russian].

Malkov, F. (1928). "A tale about a Jester who outwitted seven Jesters". New art, 8, 7 [in Ukrainian].

Nadenenko, F. (1928). Regarding the creators of modern music… Soviet art, 4, 7 [in Ukrainian].

Opera before public criticism. (1928). Soviet art, 10, 4–8 [in Ukrainian].

Pidlypska, A. (2020). Ballet criticism of Alexei Gvozdev. Bulletin of KNUKiM, issue 42, 198–204 [in Ukrainian].

Soviet art: a weekly magazine of artistic, theatrical and club life. (1928), 2 [in Ukrainian].

Soviet art: a weekly magazine of artistic, theatrical and club life (1928), 3 [in Ukrainian].

Rudin, P. (1928). In my opinion The Jester. Soviet art, 4, 6–7 [in Ukrainian].

Stanishevskyi, Yu. (1986). Ballet Theater of Soviet Ukraine: 1925–1985: Ways and Problems of Development. Kyiv : Muzychna Ukraina [in Ukrainian].

Stanishevskyi, Yu. (2002). Taras Shevchenko National Academic Opera and Ballet Theater of Ukraine: History and Modernity. Kyiv : Muzychna Ukraina [in Ukrainian].

Stefanovych, M. (1968). Kyiv State Order of Lenin Academic Opera and Ballet Theater of the USSR. Taras Shevchenko: a historical essay. Kyiv : Mystetstvo [in Ukrainian]

Suric, E. (1981). "The Tale of the Jester of the Seven Jesters who joked". Grigorovich, Ju.N. (Eds.) (1981). Ballet: an encyclopedia. Moscow: Soviet Encyclopedia, 467 [in Russian].

Timofeeva, M.N. (2016). The theme of skomorokhs in Russian musical culture: instrumental aspect. Candidate‘s thesis. St. Petersburg [in Russian].

Triaskin, N. (1928). Against eclecticism. Soviet art, 10, 6–7 [in Ukrainian].

Shestakov, V. (2013). Sergei Prokofiev's ballets for Sergei Diaghilev's Russian Seasons. International Journal of Cultural Research, 4(13), 75–80. Retrieved from https://culturalresearch.ru/files/open_issues/04_2013/IJCR_04(13)_2013_shestakov.pdf [in Russian].

Issue

Section

Choreography