Zavdat Safin, Marat Zagidullin, Ruslan Sitdikov


Abstract. This paper provides an analysis of the legal norms of ancient Russia, identifies the rules on the
judicial process and legal liability. Translating into modern legal terminology, we can say that the following measures
of responsibility have already been applied in the judicial process of Ancient Russia and in the period of feudal disunity:
for unreasonable recourse to the court and the subsequent physical punishment - compensation for
harm (moral and health);
for the defendant’s failure to appear in court: the issuance of an extrajudicial certificate (by default),
the respondent’s attachment, a fine;
for the witness’ failure to appear in court summoned on the initiative of the party - postponement of
the burden of proof;
for providing inadmissible evidence (in some categories of cases, for example, loans) - postponement
of the burden of proof;
for deception of the court (when considering complaints against actions of police officers) -
deprivation of the authorities of police officers and/or deprivation of the right to sue;
for abuse of authority by bailiffs - a fine;
for failure to fulfill a judicial act on a voluntary basis - an enforcement fee, execution;
for violation of the court order - a fine;
for making an unjust decision by a judge – moral responsibility only.
Keywords: legal responsibility, civil procedure, Ancient Russia, procedural responsibility.

Full Text:



Maleshin D., Silvestri E., Sitgikov R., Valeev D. Reforming Russian Civil Procedure. Russian Law Journal . 2016;4(1):142 -


Valeev D.K., Baranov S.Y. The reform of the civil procedural legislation: world trends // Life Science Journal. 2014. №

(12s). P. 728-731

Kochkina L.M. On the peculiarities of judicial bodies in the Novgorod republic // The state and regions. No. 1 (1), 2011. P.

-56. // URL: accessed date: 04.08.2018

Mikhailov M.M. Selected works / Ed.: D.Kh. Valeev, M.M. Mikhailov.- M.: Statute, 2014.- 312 p. (Classic civil process). -

p. 55.

Chelyshev M.Yu., Tufetulov A.M., Valeev D.Kh. Fighting corruption in Russia: the system of civil law means // Kazan

University Law Review. 2016. № 1. P. 45-57.

Ianin V.L. “I sent you a birchbark letter...” (Edition 3, revised and supplemented with new findings, with an afterword by A.

Zalizniak). Moscow, Publishing House “Iazyki Russkoi Kultury”, 1998. p. 174

Valeev D.Kh., Sitdikov R.B., Novikov I.A. Civil procedure in the CIS: current state and prospect of development // Journal

of Economics and Economic Education Research. Volume 17. Special Issue 2. 2016. P. 310-316.

Momotov V.V. Formation of Russian medieval law in the IX - XIV centuries. Monograph / Momotov V.V. - M.: Zertsalo-M,

- 416 p. - p.342.

Valeev D.K, Sitdikov R.B, Sitdikova R.I, Gabidullina, A.I. A mediation agreement in labour relations. Russia and

Italy//Journal of Organizational Culture, Communications and Conflict. - 2016. - Vol.20, Is.SpecialIssue4. - P.24-28.

Kochkina L.M. On the principles of judicial proceedings on the Novgorod judicial letter, 2011 URL: accessed date: 23 October 2017