Cluster analysis of the effectiveness of management of higher education institutions




cluster analysis, k-means method, agglomerative cluster analysis, university management level


The object of research is the internal structure of management in universities. The research problem is to confirm the causal relationship between management and rating. Higher education is one of the most important indicators of the level of development of the state. That is why many countries of the world attach great importance to the issue of the quality of higher education. Different international and national university ranking systems of universities were created to reflect the quality of education in the corresponding higher educational institutions. Currently, university ranking includes such criteria as quality of education, indicators of employment of university graduates, the demand for the graduates in the labor market, the symbiosis of science, education and business, and mobility of students. These indicators are a direct result of effective management in universities. Based on this hypothesis, the paper makes an assumption about the possibility of clustering universities in the Republic of Kazakhstan in order to determine the effectiveness of management. The authors consider three clustering models: clear and fuzzy clustering based on k-means and agglomerative cluster analysis. It should be noted that the clustering of universities makes it possible to determine some consistency in relation to the organization of university management. The division of universities into clusters according to the degree of deterioration in management makes it possible to create a kind of hierarchical ranking of the organization of management of university activities. This creates prerequisites for analyzing the internal structure of management in leading universities with the purpose of studying and adopting these practices by universities in lower clusters

Author Biographies

Aidar Mambetkaziyev, Kazakh-American Free University


Department of Business

Zhassulan Baikenov, Kazakh-American Free University

First Vice-President

Department of Business

Galina Konopyanova, Kazakh-American Free University

PhD, Professor

Department of Business


  1. European Journal of Higher Education. Scimago Journal & Country Rank. Available at:
  2. The Journal of Higher Education. Available at:
  3. Hazelkorn, E. (2015). Rankings and the reshaping of higher education. UK: Palgrave Macmillan, 304. doi:
  4. Roghanian, P., Rasli, A., Gheysari, H. (2012). Productivity Through Effectiveness and Efficiency in the Banking Industry. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 40, 550–556. doi:
  5. Astakhova, N. I. (2019). Management. Moscow: Yurayt Publishing House.
  6. Higgins, J. C. (1989). Performance measurement in universities. European Journal of Operational Research, 38 (3), 358–368. doi:
  7. Van Dyke, N. (2005). Twenty Years of University Report Cards. Higher Education in Europe, 30 (2), 103–125. doi:
  8. Usher, A., Savino, M., (2006). A world of difference: A global survey of university league tables. Ontario: Educational Policy Institute.
  9. Lazzarotti, V., Manzini, R., Mari, L. (2011). A model for R&D performance measurement. International Journal of Production Economics, 134 (1), 212–223. doi:
  10. Wu, H.-Y., Chen, J.-K., Chen, I.-S., Zhuo, H.-H. (2012). Ranking universities based on performance evaluation by a hybrid MCDM model. Measurement, 45 (5), 856–880. doi:
  11. Nail, N., Gorobets, D. V. (2016). Evaluation of the effectiveness of management development institutions of higher education on the basis of the factor and criterion model. International Journal of Environmental & Science Education, 11 (18), 12167–12182. Available at:
  12. Asaul, A. N., Kaparov, B. M. (2007). Management of a higher educational institution in an innovative economy. Saint Petersburg: “Humanystyka”.
  13. Bulatova, R. M., Tuguz, Yu. R., Filin, N. N. (2013). Evaluation of the effectiveness of universities on the basis of fuzzy methods. Fundamental Research, 11 (2), 238–243.
  14. Levshina, V. V., Shimokhina, V. V. (2007). Evaluation of the effectiveness of the quality management system of an educational organization. Problems of Modern Economics, 23, 18–24.
  15. Karlovsky, A. V. (2008). Formation of a system of indicators of the activity of a higher educational institution. Quality, Innovation, Education, 9, 16–23.
  16. Stepanov, S. A. (2004). Model and criteria for the effectiveness of the intra-university quality management system. Quality, Innovation, Education, 1, 30–37.
  17. Ruzieva, E., Nurgaliyeva, A., Duisenbayeva, B., Kulumbetova, D., Zhapbarkhanova, M. (2020). Optimization of the lecture training strategy for students. Entrepreneurship and Sustainability Issues, 7 (3), 2407–2418. doi:
  18. Bishimbaeva, S. K., Nurasheva, K. K., Nurmukhanbetova, A. A. (2017). Key assessment indicators and criteria for university innovation as elements of the quality management system. International Research Journal, 11 (65), 136–141.
  19. Karur, S., Murthy, M. V. R. (2013). Survey and Analysis of University Clustering. International Journal of Artificial Intelligence & Applications, 4 (4), 127–144. doi:
  20. Chang, W., Ji, X., Liu, Y., Xiao, Y., Chen, B., Liu, H., Zhou, S. (2020). Analysis of University Students’ Behavior Based on a Fusion K-Means Clustering Algorithm. Applied Sciences, 10 (18), 6566. doi:
  21. Rapp, K., Büchele, G., Jähnke, A. G., Weiland, S. K. (2006). A cluster-randomized trial on smoking cessation in German student nurses. Preventive Medicine, 42 (6), 443–448. doi:
  22. Battaglia, O. R., Paola, B. D., Fazio, C. (2016). A New Approach to Investigate Students’ Behavior by Using Cluster Analysis as an Unsupervised Methodology in the Field of Education. Applied Mathematics, 07 (15), 1649–1673. doi:
  23. Head, M., Ziolkowski, N. (2012). Understanding student attitudes of mobile phone features: Rethinking adoption through conjoint, cluster and SEM analyses. Computers in Human Behavior, 28 (6), 2331–2339. doi:
  24. Antonenko, P. D., Toy, S., Niederhauser, D. S. (2012). Using cluster analysis for data mining in educational technology research. Educational Technology Research and Development, 60 (3), 383–398. doi:
  25. Yang, C. Y., Liu, J. Y., Huang, S. (2020). Research on early warning system of college students’ behavior based on big data environment. The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, XLII-3/W10, 659–665. doi:
  26. Sorour, S. E., Mine, T., Goda, K., Hirokawa, S. (2015). A Predictive Model to Evaluate Student Performance. Journal of Information Processing, 23 (2), 192–201. doi:
  27. Peng, K., Leung, V. C. M., Huang, Q. (2018). Clustering Approach Based on Mini Batch Kmeans for Intrusion Detection System Over Big Data. IEEE Access, 6, 11897–11906. doi:
  28. Yuhui, P., Yuan, Z., Huibao, Y. (2018). Development of a representative driving cycle for urban buses based on the K-means cluster method. Cluster Computing, 22 (S3), 6871–6880. doi:
  29. Niukkanen, A., Arponen, O., Nykänen, A., Masarwah, A., Sutela, A., Liimatainen, T. et al. (2017). Quantitative Volumetric K-Means Cluster Segmentation of Fibroglandular Tissue and Skin in Breast MRI. Journal of Digital Imaging, 31 (4), 425–434. doi:
  30. Abbasi, S., Nejatian, S., Parvin, H., Rezaie, V., Bagherifard, K. (2018). Clustering ensemble selection considering quality and diversity. Artificial Intelligence Review, 52 (2), 1311–1340. doi:
  31. Bagherinia, A., Minaei-Bidgoli, B., Hossinzadeh, M., Parvin, H. (2018). Elite fuzzy clustering ensemble based on clustering diversity and quality measures. Applied Intelligence, 49 (5), 1724–1747. doi:
  32. Nazari, A., Dehghan, A., Nejatian, S., Rezaie, V., Parvin, H. (2017). A comprehensive study of clustering ensemble weighting based on cluster quality and diversity. Pattern Analysis and Applications, 22 (1), 133–145. doi:
  33. Independent Agency for Quality Assurance in Education. Available at:
Cluster analysis of the effectiveness of management of higher education institutions




How to Cite

Mambetkaziyev, A. ., Baikenov, Z., & Konopyanova, G. (2022). Cluster analysis of the effectiveness of management of higher education institutions . Eastern-European Journal of Enterprise Technologies, 6(3 (120), 26–31.



Control processes